Showing posts with label crunch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crunch. Show all posts

03 April 2013

DGRPG Design Diary #9: Fightin'!

Combat is divided into rounds, little five-second parcels of time that make it easier for everyone to keep track of what's going on. Each round everyone gets an action - this can be something like opening or closing a door, retrieving something from a pocket, or trying to beat the tar out of an opponent. Everyone gets an action every round (unless constrained by something), and once everyone's taken an action a new round begins.

Combat Resolution

Alright, what do we need to know so that characters can hit each other until someone loses?

  • Who goes first?
  • How hard is it to hit the target?
  • How much damage does a successful blow inflict?
  • How much damage can a character sustain?

Who goes first?

At the start of each combat, roll a d20 and add your character's WILY and DEFT modifiers to represent (a) how quickly they decide what to do and (b) how quickly they can act on it. This is their Initiative. Character actions are processed from highest Initiative to lowest. Once everyone's acted, a new round begins.

How hard is it to hit the target?

By "hit" we mean a blow which connects well enough to do damage; in any individual combat round there's likely to be a back-and-forth exchange of blows, most of which miss or are intercepted or glance off without inflicting any appreciable harm.

Using the target numbers from Design Diary #7 we'll say that trying to hit someone in a combat situation is Taxing - you're trying to land a blow on them without getting hit yourself - so you need to roll higher than 15 to hit. Additionally, characters who are more agile will generally be harder to hit in the first place as they dodge around, and clumsy or sluggish characters will be easier. To reflect that, let's apply the defending character's DEFT modifier to the target number.

At the GM's option, characters who engage in tactics which give them an edge (attacking from ambush, taking the high ground, throwing dust in their opponent's eyes) might be granted bonuses to hit their target. Generally this should be on the order of a +1 per modifying factor, up to a maximum total of +3 if they really pile on the dirty tricks.

How much damage does a successful blow inflict? Damage is based on the attacker's weapon, adjusted by their BRUTE modifier, and reduced by the defender's armour. Heavier armour provides greater protection from blows, but also reduces the defender's maximum DEFT modifier accordingly.

So, roll dice (based on weapon type), add the attacker's BRUTE modifier and deduct the defender's armour rating; reduce the defender's Vigour by the result.

How much damage can a character sustain?

Vigour? What's that? Oh yes, that. As characters progress in experience they become better able to survive fights, which we'll represent with a stat called Vigour. This is something of an abstraction, representing their overall ability to keep fighting - a combination of stamina, pain threshold, physical resilience and raw determination. When a character runs out of Vigour they are out of the fight - unconscious or worse.

Vigour increases by a moderate amount as the character gains levels to represent characters becoming better at resisting exhaustion, enduring pain, and fighting on in spite of injury. Fighty classes will tend to gain Vigour at a faster rate than less-fighty classes. Whoever runs out of Vigour first is out of the fight - exhausted, unconscious, cowed, or otherwise incapacitated. Alternatively they could keep on fighting anyway - but this runs the risk of character death, and there's no coming back from that.

Summary

Combat is generally a matter of attrition. Some character classes (the Jinx in particular) will have abilities they can throw into the mix to make things more interesting, but at its heart it's a matter of characters hitting one another until someone falls over.

18 January 2013

DGRPG Design Diary #7: Core Mechanics Review

A quick recap of the core mechanics, with some provisional values.

Task Resolution:

The central task resolution mechanic used to determine success or failure. This can apply to setting or disarming a cunning trap, jumping over an obstacle, climbing a rope, attacking an adversary, intimidating a subordinate, whatever.

d20 + modifiers vs. target number

I'm going to try and keep the range of modifiers pretty tight to avoid undue inflation as characters improve over time.

Modifiers

Attribute modifiers are derived from the PC's Attributes, and use the Attribute most relevant to the task at hand. Such modifiers are kept deliberately low to reduce the emphasis on number-crunching character optimisation by ensuring that even a character with non-optimised Attributes remains playable.

Attribute 3 4-5 6-8 9-12 13-15 16-17 18
Modifier -3 -2 -1 0 +1 +2 +3

Equipment modifiers are conferred by special items, weapons, etc. An enchanted dagger might grant a +1 modifier to damage inflicted, an enchanted helm might grant a -1 modifier to damage received. Such items are likely to be rare and highly prized.

Situational modifiers are conferred by environmental factors which help or hinder the performance of a task - a PC might enjoy a positive modifier if assisted by companions, given extra time to perform the task, or similarly favourable conditions; correspondingly a PC might suffer a negative modifier while on fire, or in pitch darkness, or hanging by one leg from the ceiling, or likewise distracted. It is entirely possible (and indeed encouraged) to seek advantage by inflicting such negative modifiers upon adversaries.

There is a limit to the number of modifiers that can be applied to a task resolution attempt to keep things from getting silly - three modifiers or a total of +5 in each direction, whichever is lower.

Target Numbers

Target numbers vary based on the difficulty of the task at hand. To succeed at a task the total of d20 + modifiers must exceed the target number. Dice should only be rolled when there is a likelihood of failure having consequences - so hopping over a puddle of water wouldn't require a roll, but leaping a bottomless crevasse (or a puddle of acid) would.

DifficultyTarget% success
Trivial195%
Easy575%
Standard1050%
Taxing1525%
Daunting195%

The default target number is 10, which gives a 50-50 chance of success or failure for an individual of average ability. This can vary according to the task - jumping over a 3' gap might be Trivial, a 5' gap might be Easy, a 10' gap Standard, a 15' gap Taxing, and a 20' gap Daunting.

I've also been made aware of a game called Dungeon World which uses a "partial success" mechanic - such that borderline task resolution rolls might succeed, but with a cost or consequence. It's an idea that's intriguing to me, so I'll be researching it further.

31 July 2012

DGRPG Design Diary #5: Primary Attributes

Another crunchy Design Diary today, in which I flail around with numbers some more.

Each character has six primary attributes loosely mirroring the STR/DEX/CON/INT/WIS/CHA characteristics of D&D, slightly tweaked for the sake of symmetry. The names of the attributes are provisional at this point, and may change if I find more appropriate or flavourful synonyms.

The primary attributes are divided between Physical and Mental; in each category, one attribute of each type:

  • Action - Doing stuff.
  • Evasion - Dodging stuff.
  • Resistance - Enduring stuff.
AttributeTypeDescription
BRUTEishnessAction, PhysicalStrength, physical power, ability to hit things and break stuff.
DEFTnessEvasion, PhysicalDexterity, physical agility, ability to jump out of the way, juggle, manipulate objects.
GUTSYnessResistance, PhysicalConstitution, physical resilience, ability to absorb damage, endure pain, resist disease or poison, perform acts of extended physical exertion.
CLEVERnessAction, MentalIntelligence, mental power, ability to outsmart opponents, recall facts, notice details, present persuasive arguments, focus magical energy.
WILYnessEvasion, MentalWisdom, mental agility, ability to navigate bureaucracy, think on one's feet, react quickly, bend the rules, shirk responsibility, divert blame.
STUBbornnessResistance, MentalCharisma, mental resilience, strength of personality, ability to issue orders to subordinates or resist orders from superiors.

Direct vs. Derived Values

It'd be good to find a way for these values to be directly relevant to gameplay; this could be achieved by using the attribute values themselves in task resolution (as described in the previous Design Diary), but that can lead to cumbersome mental arithmetic in-game. It might be that attribute values are best left as a way of gauging relative ability between characters, with derived values being used in-game for the sake of speed and simplicity.

What kind of derived values could be used?

Assuming primary attributes follow the D&D model (usually between 3 and 18, with some outliers), a number of options are available.

  • Flat modifiers - an unchanging numerical modifier depending on how far the attribute value is above or below the mean. Modifiers may be positive or negative, and are applied to the result of the task resolution roll.
  • Dice modifiers - additional dice are rolled depending on how far the attribute value is above or below the mean. Results may be added to or subtracted from the result of the task resolution roll.

My current model has the primary attributes determined directly, either randomly by dice-roll (ie: 3d6 or some close variant), or (possibly) through a point-buy mechanic.

So some example attribute-derived modifiers might look something like this:

Attribute Dist. Flat 1 Flat 2 Dice (mean)
1 - -9 -5 -1d10 (-5.5)
2 - -8 -4 -1d10 (-5.5)
3 0.46% -7 -4 -1d8 (-4.5)
4 1.39% -6 -3 -1d8 (-4.5)
5 2.78% -5 -3 -1d6 (-3.5)
6 4.63% -4 -2 -1d6 (-3.5)
7 6.94% -3 -2 -1d4 (-2.5)
8 9.72% -2 -1 -1d4 (-2.5)
9 11.57% -1 -1 0
10 12.50% 0 0 0
11 12.50% 0 0 0
12 11.57% +1 +1 0
13 9.72% +2 +1 +1d4 (+2.5)
14 6.94% +3 +2 +1d4 (+2.5)
15 4.63% +4 +2 +1d6 (+3.5)
16 2.78% +5 +3 +1d6 (+3.5)
17 1.39% +6 +3 +1d8 (+4.5)
18 0.46% +7 +4 +1d8 (+4.5)
19 - +8 +4 +1d10 (+5.5)
20 - +9 +5 +1d10 (+5.5)

The modifiers here are pretty arbitrary for now, and presented to illustrate the options available.

The "Dist." column shows the probability distribution for each attribute value assuming they're generated by rolling 3d6 - this gives a normal distribution of results, in which you're much more likely to end up with a value close to the average than near the extremes. For example, the chance of rolling a 10 or 11 is 25% (and the chance of rolling between 9 and 12 is just shy of 50%), whereas the chance of rolling 17-18 (or 3-4) is only a little over 2%. This distribution is skewed if you use an alternative method of generating attributes (for example, roll 4d6 and ignore the lowest die, or roll 10 times and pick the best 6 results) but as a general guideline it's useful enough.

Adjusting the relationship between attributes and modifiers allows the value of each point of modifier to be increased or decreased. For example, an item that gives a +1 bonus is equivalent to a single extra attribute point under Flat 1, but two attribute points under Flat 2, so it makes a bigger difference.

Meanwhile the mean modifiers given by the Dice column are similar to those in Flat 2, except there's a much wider range of possible values - an attribute of 18 gives a reliable +4 bonus under Flat 2, and while +1d8 gives a mean value of +4.5 an individual roll could give a result anywhere between +1 and +8. There's a potential for it to make a really big difference to the outcome - or hardly any difference at all. This could be positive (as it means that even a sub-optimal attribute might still has a chance of success) or negative (as it means that even high attributes have a risk of failure).

Either way the additional randomness could be a desirable feature, as it encourages the player to rely on more than just having large numbers on their character sheet - every roleplayer knows how fickle the dice gods can be.

29 July 2012

DGRPG Design Diary #4: Task Resolution

This involves a lot of poking numbers, wrangling probabilities, and dusting off some high-school probability and statistics lessons. I've found AnyDice to be very useful for visualising things.

The basic mechanism by which tasks are resolved; this part is pretty simple, the complexity comes with working out how and when to apply modifiers, and how to interpret the results.

d20 + modifiers vs. Target Number

There are a number of choices to be made here.

Use an attribute, or a modifier derived from that attribute?

The mean (average) value of a d20 roll is 10.5, so a target number of "more than 10" gives a chance of success of 50%. Assume the average attribute to be 10.5 (the mean result of rolling 3d6).

d20+attribute gives a mean result of 21, so a target number of "more than 20" gives a chance of success slightly above 50%.

If rolls are modified based on an attribute (for example, +/-1 point for every point above/below the average of 10-11) then as long as average attributes give a modifier of zero, a target number of "more than 10" gives a chance of success of 50%. For example:

Attribute 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10-11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Modifier -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 +1 +2 +3 +4 +5 +6 +7

Using attributes keeps things simpler on the character sheet; modifiers generally use smaller values that are easier to deal with, but there may be more of them involved. For example:

14 (d20 roll) + 16 (attribute) + 2 (situational modifier), target number >20

vs.

14 (d20 roll) + 5 (attribute-derived modifier) + 2 (situational modifier), target number >10

Conclusion: Undecided at present; on the one hand using modifiers means adding smaller numbers together, which is less taxing from a mental arithmetic point of view; on the other hand I'm advised that players hate negative modifiers, even if the underlying mathematics are the same.

Use a flat modifier, or additional dice?

Even if we use "d20+attribute", there are circumstances in which we might still want to apply modifiers - skill tests, situational advantage, that kind of thing. So is it preferable to just apply a flat modifier, or roll extra dice?

1d20 gives a mean value of 10.5, with results between 1 and 20.

1d20+5 gives a mean value of 15.5, with results between 6 and 25.

1d20+1d10 gives a mean value of 16, with results between 2 and 30.

So while both of those modifiers give a similar mean result, the range of possible results is wider when using dice rather than a flat modifier, though the results are on a bell curve (higher likelihood of rolling values closer to the mean than to the extremes).

Conclusion: I quite like the idea of rolling extra dice, but that may dilute the "roll a d20" core mechanic. Also, rolling multiple dice can be quite "swingy" - +1d10 will on average act as a +5.5 bonus, in practice it can be anything from a +1 to a +10. Meanwhile a +5 bonus is always a +5 bonus. Using flat modifiers most of the time with extra dice in special circumstances might be a decent compromise.